More Than
Memories
By
Julie Jurkovich
October 2001
Ben Cartwright slowly stretched and
opened his eyes to the dark room. He lay
still for several minutes, hearing the silence about him. As the room slowly took on the grey hues of
dawn, he thought about the sounds he usually heard in the early morning. Adam’s steady footsteps would have passed his
room and descended the stairs, pausing by the front door while he put on his
hat and strapped on his gunbelt, before leaving for
the barn to tend to the chores. Then,
Hoss’s lumbering tread would sound from his room as he washed and dressed,
followed by his heavy, echoing feet as they followed his older brother. Finally, Ben would emerge from his room, and
almost always step into his youngest son’s room to shake him awake. Then, he would carefully descend the
steps. Hop Sing always had a cup of
coffee waiting for him. He would drink
it as he strapped on his gun and put on his hat, and then leave to talk with
the foreman about the tasks for the day.
Finally, he shoved back the blankets
and swung his legs over the edge of the bed.
He might as well begin the day.
It was one he had dreaded for a long time, and it wasn’t going to be any
easier for delay. He rubbed his eyes,
then rose and started pulling on his trousers.
As he washed up, he felt uncomfortably alert, and wished he could spend
the day in bed. Something was wrong; something was
missing....
Of course, his sons were
missing. Adam had gone to
Ben sighed. Little Joe.....The possibilities for trouble
with that hot-headed youngster, even with the steadying hand of Brett, one of
Ben’s long-time and most trusted hands, were endless. Joe was angry before he even left. He complained that he should have been
allowed to go to
After
he shaved, Ben buttoned his shirt and tucked it in, fastened his belt, brushed
his hair, and
walked the familiar path down the hall, as he had done for so many years. As he descended the staircase, he thought for
a fleeting moment of his three wives, the women who had made his present
happiness and fulfillment possible, and tried to chase away the
ache that threatened to overtake and stop his heart. Sometimes,
his memories hurt so much that he wished his heart wouldstop,
and he could join his wives in death. At
moments such as that, he was grateful for the presence of his three sons, each
a visible reminder of the love who had left him years before. Perhaps that was why part of him never really
wanted Adam, or Hoss, or even Joe, though he was still young, to leave him and
settle down with a
woman. He needed them here. Not just to help run the Ponderosa; they could do that
from a house several miles away. He
needed them here to keep him from remembering, and wanting to die from, the
memories of his lost loves. Ben had lost
three wives. How many times could a man
love, and still recover? How long could
he go on, pretending that he still could live?
No, he needed Adam, Hoss, and Joe near him, so he didn’t have to think
about the loss of the women he loved more than life. After all, each son was a gift; a visible, tangible
remembrance of his mother.
As Ben turned from the staircase and
entered the living room, the sun was shining through the window at the end of
the house near the dining room table.
The entire room was illumined by a golden light, which he surely had
seen before, but had seldom noticed or appreciated. He looked about him in wonder. The striped satin couch glowed in the early
morning light, and dust motes swam over it.
The golden wood of the coffee table absorbed the lustrous rays of the
sun and emitted a resplendent glow, which Ben knew would be lost to more
reserved tones as the day progressed, and the year moved inexorably toward Winter.
He went to the dining room table,
and looked at the huge, empty wooden monolith with longing. It never seemed so big when it was surrounded
by people. But even the presence of his
sons couldn’t take up enough space, or fill the hole in his heart that had been
left by each of their mothers.
Swallowing a lump in his throat, he sat down, wishing in vain for a
company of sons, friends, neighbors, and loved ones
to fill the space at the table, in the house, and in his heart. His mind strayed to memories from about this
table.
“Where
is Joseph? Doesn’t he know I expect him
to get himself up in the mornings? Why
must I always fight to get him to do his fair share of work around here?”
“Now,
Pa, calm down. Just calm down! I’ll go up and get him, and make sure he gets
out to do that fence mendin’
with the rest of the hands you had in mind for the job.”
Lost in his memories, Ben reached
out for his coffee. His coffee! Where was it?
Hop Sing always had it here, waiting for him. Often as not, he emerged from the kitchen as
soon as Ben came down the stairs, and poured him a fresh cup. Ben always savoured that coffee.
Of course: Hop Sing wasn’t here. He had gone to
As he approached his den, he saw that the
package was a bottle with a card under it.
Piled on either side of it were packages wrapped in bright paper. He smiled as he picked up the bottle, and
slipped the card from under it.
To Pa, on your birthday.
We hope you have a good day, and know that we miss you very much.
With love,
Adam
Hoss
Joe
With a faraway smile, Ben picked up
the bottle, opened it, and sniffed appreciatively. His sons certainly had good taste, and knew
what he liked. Well, it was too early in
the morning for brandy. He resealed the
bottle reluctantly, and thought of the times that he had turned to drinking, or
thought of going on a drunk, to drown his grief. Each time, it was the knowledge that his sons
needed him that kept him going. How
often had he pulled himself from the brink of despair; from the bleak prospect of
the absence of love in his life, only to realize that he did have love, but of
a different nature and need? Thank God
for his sons. Had it not been for them,
he might have needlessly thrown away his life in his grief. He looked at the presents, but decided to
wait until after breakfast to open them.
As he entered the kitchen, he looked
uncertainly around. This was Hop Sing’s domain, and he welcomed no trespassers - not even
his employer. He saw the coffee pot on
the stove, and found it filled with water.
The container with ground coffee was set next to the coffee pot. He smiled.
Doubtless, this was Hoss’s doing.
His middle son’s heart was as big as the rest of him. Since he was never able to go without food,
he would be certain to see to it that his father was taken care of on his
birthday.
Ben opened the stove to add the
wood, and found it was already done. He
had only to open the drafts, start the fire, measure the coffee in, and heat
the pot. Well, that would take a while. He might as well go open at least one present
from his sons.
He returned to his desk, and sat
down, looking at the presents. Which one
should he open first? His hand went
instinctively to the largest one, then stopped, as he
chided himself for behaving like a child on Christmas, and greedily opening the
biggest gift first. Then, he thought,
“Why not? There’s no one here to see
me!” He lifted the large, bulky gift
from below the one on top of it, and began tearing away the bright paper.
Several layers of heavy paper lay
below it. He carefully removed those,
and found a basket wrapped in coarse paper, a sealed note, and a smaller, heavy
package wrapped in cloths. Ben unwound
the paper and found a basket full of rolls, sweet rolls, and sweetmeats, all
carefully wrapped. He smiled as he
searched through the treats, and looked at the note. To Pa,
the large, careful lettering spelled, and he recognized Hoss’s writing. He broke the seal.
Dear Pa,
I know that this little package don’t seem like much, but
I thought you might get hankerin for somethin sweet on your birthday, especially without Hop
Sing there. I figger
you can eat some of the rolls with your breakfast, and space the rest out
through the day. You know we’ll be home
in a few days, and we’ll have a proper celebration then. Meanwhile, I hope you like these rolls. I asked Mrs. Thomas to fix ‘em up special for you, seeing as how it was your birthday
and all, and you’d be alone. She about had a fit, and wanted to bring’em
out special, but I told her that you’d probly rather
open your presents in peace and quiet.
The other little gift is something I found in Ma’s
Bible. I know you told me once that you
hardly ever looked at it after she died, and I thought you might like it. I asked Adam about it, and he said he thought
you would. I know it ain’t Cristmas, but this picture reminds me of Ma, the way you
told me she was.
Love,
Hoss
Ben removed the cloths from the
heavier item, and saw the back of a picture frame. He slowly turned over the heavy, gilded frame and saw a
painting of a little blonde girl with long, curly tresses flowing over her
shoulders and about her face. On her
head she wore a crown of candles; over one arm she carried a basket of fruit,
while in the other hand, she carried a wooden flute with a sprig of holly tied
about it.
For a moment, tears blinded
Ben. He put the picture hastily on the
desk before him so he wouldn’t drop it, and covered his face. Tears streamed down his cheeks, and when he
looked about him, the sunlight nearly blinded him. He wiped his eyes, picked up the picture, and
forced himself to look at it. This was
the Christkindl, or
The smell of coffee reached
Ben. He carefully rewrapped the picture
in the cloths, and carried the rolls and sweetmeats to the dining room
table. In the kitchen, he removed the
coffeepot from the stove, nearly burning his fingers. The memory of Inger
bringing gifts stopped the curse as it came to his lips. He found some eggs that Hop Sing had left in
the springhouse, and several minutes later sat down at the dining room table
with a breakfast of eggs, rolls, sweetrolls, and
coffee.
The sun had risen above the large
window, and filled the room with a vibrant glow. As Ben finished his breakfast, he thought how
different it appeared now that he was alone.
The light itself spoke of chores to be done; tasks to accomplish, and
errands to run. It beckoned him outside
as surely as if his foreman had knocked on the door and requested his presence.
He left the dishes on the table from
habit, strapped on his gun, put on his hat, and left the house. He resisted the pull of the remaining gifts,
and shut the door behind him. There
would be time for more reminiscing after his work was done.
No one was in the yard, and Ben
chided himself for not doing the chores before he ate. He went into the barn, and found all the
stock cared for. Stalls had been mucked
out, and mangers were filled. He had
always insisted that his sons care for their horses and do those morning chores
before breakfast, instead of leaving it to the hands. They must have asked one of the hands to do
it for them while they were gone.
Ben mounted Buck, and went to join
the hands who were digging new post holes and
stringing new wire. As he approached, he
could hear them shouting, laughing, and singing snatches of songs. He heard the echoing thud of an axe as it cut
off an extra length of wood, the occasional neigh of a horse, and suddenly, a
loud crash, followed by a burst of laughter.
Raising his eyebrows, Ben rode over a hill to see a load of fence posts
piled on the ground below a wagon, which had tilted back and spilled its load. Rising sheepishly from the ground was a hand
whom Ben recognized as Curly.
“Uh-oh, Curly, you did that just in
time for the boss to see!” shouted someone.
Everyone turned to see Ben approaching, and laughed again.
Shorty,
the foreman, rode to Ben. “Mornin’ ,
Mr. Cartwright,” he said. “What can I do
for you?”
“I came to help,” replied Ben, with
some surprise. His eyes strayed toward
Curly, and the fenceposts next to him. “Guess I know where to begin.
As he rode toward the wagon, Shorty hastened to ride beside him. “No need for you to do that, Mr. Cartwright,”
he said; “no need at all. Curly wasn’t watchin’ what he was doin’,
bumped into the wagon, and spilled ever’thing all
over. He and a couple of the others can
pick it up.”
Ben reined Buck toward the fenceline. “Well,
then, I’ll help dig the post holes, then.”
“Oh, there’s no need for that,
either, Mr. Cartwright,” sputtered Shorty. “We’ve got everything under control here.”
Ben looked pointedly at the
scattered poles and the laughing, joking men.
“Well, we did, until Curly turned
around,” Shorty hastened to add.
As Ben continued to the place where
holes were being dug, Shorty followed him. “Mr. Cartwright, why don’t you just go on
back to the house and relax today?
There’s no -”
Ben turned toward him with eyebrows
lowered and dark eyes smoldering. “Are you implying that I’m too old and feeble
to do my share of work around here?” he thundered.
“Why no, sir, not
at all, sir! It’s just -
well....Mr. Adam spoke to me afore he left, and he told me that since today’s
you’re birthday, he didn’t want you doin’
anything. That’s all, sir.”
Ben glared at him. “I appreciate your and Adam’s wishes, but if
I don’t work, I’ll go crazy in that house!”
“Well, then, sir, why don’t you take
a ride? Go into town, have some
fun. Or go off someplace you’ve been wantin’
to go, and haven’t been able to for a while?
I’m just trying to follow Mr. Adam’s ord - er, uh, do as he suggested, sir.”
Ben bit back a retort that Adam
didn’t give the orders; he did. But Adam
had only been thinking of him when he asked the foreman not to let him work on
this day. He thought of the crystal
waters of
“Yes, sir,” replied Shorty.
“I’ll see you tomorrow, then,”
replied Ben, and rode back to the house.
Shorty
sighed with relief, and wondered if Adam had known how difficult his father
would be when asked not to work. He had
the feeling that Adam knew quite well.
As Ben entered the door, the house felt cool
and pleasant. The dining room was a
little darker, and it took a few moments for his eyes to adjust. He frowned when he saw the dishes on the
table; then laughed. He was too
accustomed to Hop Sing. He carried the
dishes into the kitchen, where he left them in the sink. Then he got a sack from a cupboard, and began
searching through the kitchen for some food to take on his excursion. A nice ride through the woodland to
He put the sack of food on the
table, and walked slowly to his desk.
Should he open the other gifts now, take them along, or wait until he
arrived home? He picked up a large box,
neatly wrapped in blue paper, with strong, flowing script written across
it. The other was more clumsily wrapped,
with a messy scrawl across it. Ben
smiled. The larger one was most
certainly from Adam: The neat wrapping
job attested to that, even if he hadn’t recognized his oldest son’s
handwriting.
He sat at his desk and carefully
pulled away the paper from the neatly wrapped package, and slowly removed the
lid. Nestled into the
box, with cloths and paper carefully placed about it so it could not move, as
the replica of a clipper ship.
Ben held his breath as he cautiously
removed it from the box, then gave a gasp of amazement
when he saw the magnificent piece of work before him. It was exquisitely crafted; an exact model of the Wanderer. Polished wood formed the hull, deck, and
masts; the sails were sewn from bits of canvas, and tiny ropes of twine formed
the rigging. The anchor was made of
pewter, as was the stand that the craft rested in.
Ben was glad for the first time that
day that his sons were not home. He was
speechless, and knew he could never have thanked Adam properly had his son been
there. For the next several minutes, Ben
feasted his eyes on the delicate work of art before him. He had no doubt that Adam had ordered this
made specially for him, and had probably made several
requests in its construction. He
wondered who had crafted it, and where, and how Adam had ever gotten it home.
The silence hung heavily in the house
as Ben looked about. From the looks of
the light, it was past
As he stood, a piece of paper on the
floor caught his eye. It was folded and
sealed, and had the same flowing script on it as the package he had just
opened. He broke the seal. A small square of paper fell out into his
lap. He laid it on the desk, and proceeded
to read the note.
Dear Pa,
I wish I could be here on your birthday. None of us wanted to leave you alone on your
special day, but we all agreed that you shouldn’t have to wait for us to return
to open your gifts. When we get back,
we’ll have Hop Sing fix a birthday dinner and have a real celebration!
I know you’ll like the ship. I looked around for just the right person to
make it, and I thought he did a wonderful job.
It reminds me of Grandfather, and brings to mind the stories he told me
during my college days, and the stories you told me about him and my mother
when I was young.
While I stayed at Grandfather’s when I was in the East, I
found my mother’s book of Paradise Lost.
Pressed between the pages was a lock of hair, which I assume was hers. I never asked Grandfather about it. He was always very sad whenever we spoke of
her. I thought you might like to have it, in her
memory.
I ‘ll
see you soon.
Fondly,
Adam
Ben slowly laid the letter down, and
picked up the square of paper on his desk.
With trembling hands, he unfolded it.
A soft curl of fine black hair slid into his hand. Yes, this was his first wife’s hair. The raven-headed
The sun had passed its zenith by the
time Ben finally got underway to the lake.
He felt a sense of freedom that he hadn’t known in years. For the first time, there were no contracts,
no pressing cattlemen’s association matters to deal with, and no stray cattle
he had to dig out of holes. He could
spend the entire afternoon and much of the evening relaxing and doing as he
pleased. He thought with anticipation of
Joe’s gift in his saddlebag, and decided to wait until he had eaten to open it.
He rode Buck at his leisure under
trees, their shimmering green leaves resplendent in the golden westering sun, and entered a stand of pines. It was always darker, more solemn, and almost
silent under them. He was grateful for the
scurrying of animals in the undergrowth, and the startled cry and flurry of a
bird as it flew away. He’d had enough of
silence today, and was sure he would have his fill of it well before Hop Sing
returned in a few day’s time.
When Ben rode to the overlook by
As his mind cleared and his spirit
calmed, he rode slowly along the path at the top of the bluff. There was a nice grove in the pines ahead
where he would stop to eat a late lunch.
Then, he could go to Marie’s grave, and open his youngest son’s gift.
The clearing where he stopped was
surrounded by tall, dark Ponderosa pines, and had a rocky pinnacle overlooking
the lake. Ben leaned against the wide
girth of a pine tree, pulled his food sack from his saddlebag, and ate his
lunch. The sun sank to the top of the
pines at the west of the lake, and he remembered his present from Joe.
Reluctantly, he mounted his horse
and rode a short distance ahead to Marie’s resting place. He pulled the package from his saddlebag, and
smiled as he again saw the hurried, clumsy wrapping, and the scrawl attesting
his youngest son’s handiwork. He sat by
the tombstone, and deciphered the inscription on the gift:
To Pa
Love, Joe
Ben carefully pulled away the paper to
reveal a wooden carving of a horse.
Though small enough to fit within his hand, it stood tall and proud,
with head held high. Ben almost felt he was on its
back when he saw the mane cascading behind it and the long tail flowing after
in the wind of its speed. He smiled
when he recalled the Christmas and birthday gifts Marie had made for him and
for the children. Marie had been a
talented lady, and nothing enhanced her abilities more than her desire to
create something new to please her sons, or her husband. Ben had no doubt that this gift from Joe was
evidence of Marie’s talent . Once in a while, when he wasn’t running wild,
Joe had indicated evidence of an artistic ability that reminded Ben of the
boy’s mother. Ben was certain that Joe
had carved this independently of his brothers’ knowledge, and had unwittingly
displayed his talent.
Ben saw a roughly folded piece of
paper within the wrapping, and opened it.
Dear Pa,
This horse reminds me of Mama: her independence, her free spirit, and her
determination to conquer all who set themselves against her - or you. She was a beautiful lady, and this horse
reminds me of her.
Mama made lots of things for us while she was here. I never made anything for her. But I believe she would like this horse. It reminds me of her: free, a little wild, and carefree. Even though Mama died, I’m glad she was the
way she was.
I don’t know if I’ve done a very good job of carving this horse, but I think
she would like it. I also don’t know if
I’ve done very well in school, or doing my chores, or being your son, but I
know Mama would love me anyway.
I just want to say I love you, Pa, and I want you to be
proud of me.
I’ll work hard all my life to make you and Adam and Hoss
proud of me.
I love you,
Joseph, your youngest son
Ben closed his eyes, determined that
tears would not again overtake him. But
despite his will, he felt the dampness on his cheeks, and cursed his
weakness. Wild and free: yes, that described Marie. It also described her son. He looked at the gift again, and choked and
shuddered over the resemblance of the independent spirit of the horse to his
youngest son. No wonder he had so much
trouble with Joe, curbing his impulses, reining in his exuberance, and channeling his energy.
Joe was his mother’s son in every way.
Each of his boys was so different from the other; yet each had his own indescirbable and unmatchable gift.
“Oh, Marie,” thought Ben, “I can’t
do it. I can’t! I can’t raise our son by myself! He runs in all directions! Neither I nor both of my other sons combined
can keep his fires banked. He is every
inch your son: He has your passion, your
exuberance, your fire and loyalty, and your impulsive nature. If I don’t watch closely, he’ll destroy
himself! How can I help him to be the
best he can be? How can I raise him right
without you? He won’t go in the right
direction; he
runs after everything, good and bad, for all the right reasons!” Ben sobbed for several moments, and finally
choked out, “Oh, God, help me! Help me
with my son! All of my sons!” He buried his face in his hands and cried
long and hard.
When he raised his head several
minutes later, the sun had gone behind the mountains on the western side of the
lake. He looked at the red-gold halo
surrounding the trees, and the even deeper azure of the lake, and realized he
must go home. But he couldn’t
move. Exhaustion had paralyzed
him, and he leaned back against a nearby tree and closed his eyes. Gradually, slowly, tranquility
replaced his weariness. He opened his
eyes, and saw the sunset turning
The last light of sunset illumined
Marie’s tombstone. “Marie Cartwright, I
will always remember you,” swore Ben. He
looked at the fading light on the lake below him, and recalled
Ben raised his glistening eyes to
the last rays of the setting sun. “Father, thank you for my sons. Thank you for my wives, the loves of my
life.” His breath caught, and he stifled
a sob. “You have always pointed the
way ever so faithfully, and I trust you to do so now. Help me to lead all of my sons, especially
Joseph, in the way they should go. I
love them, Father. Let me be able to
show them that I love them, each of them, for who and
what they are. I feel so alone
sometimes. Strengthen me, and them, and
guide all of us in the right way.”
Ben again shut his eyes, and was
surprised when waves of strength slowly flowed over him. When he opened his eyes, the land about him
was dark, and the lake and the western sky held only a hint of the grandeur he
had just witnessed. But he mounted
Buck, and rode the darkened path through the pines, under the aspens, and
through the open country to the Ponderosa.
The stars that emerged from the eastern sky lit the well-trodden road to
his home.
His home. His sons’ home. Marie’s home. Everyone’s home. This home he had was built not only with the
sweat of his brow, and with the help of his sons, but also with each of his
wives. Their dreams, their
encouragement, their love, and their sons, had made it possible.
He saw a light in the window as he
approached the house, and wondered who was there. When he dismounted, Shorty
emerged from the bunkhouse, and insisted on putting up Buck. Ben went into the house, and found the fire
lit, a lamp lighting the room, and a place set for him at the table. As he looked on in wonder, Hop Sing emerged
from the kitchen.
“Welcome home, Mr. Cartwright!” he
exclaimed. “You wash up, and I bring
dinner! You late! I think you not coming!”
Ben stared at him in
consternation. “I - I didn’t know you
were coming back today, Hop Sing! What a
surprise!”
Hop Sing laughed. “You really surprised! Of course I come back today! Today is special day - Mr. Cartwright’s
birthday! Mr. Adam, and Hoss and Joe,
they ask me to try to come back today! I
have good dinner fixed! You wash up, and
eat!”
Ben unbuckled his gunbelt, and left it and his hat on the credenza. As he approached the table, Hop Sing furiously
gestured toward the washbasin. “No,
no!! You wash up first! Then, you eat!”
Ben smiled as he complied. Everything was almost back to normal. Once his sons returned home, he would forget
what it felt like to be alone. He dried
his hands on a towel, and sat at the table, anticipating what smelled like
fried chicken and potatoes. What a shame
the boys weren’t here to share it. But
they would be back, and then, they could celebrate together.
Yes, they would be back. They would always be back. And together, they would continue the love,
laughter, and spirit of the Ponderosa.
As he hungrily tucked into his birthday meal, he realized that with the
legacy of his three beloved wives, and the indomitable spirit of his sons, he
could never be alone again.
THE END